One of the many things I enjoy about Italy is sampling all the modes of public transportation. So here, from a recent visit to southern Italy and Florence, are a few notes and anecdotes…..
Frecciarossa
Still the gold standard for me, the high-speed Frecciarossa trains are fast, efficient, and comfortable. (The train from Naples to Florence – several a day – travels the 300 miles in under three hours.) And like every other mode of public transportation in Italy, they are full. If I were to give a half-star deduction for the Frecciarossa it would be for the food service. The sandwiches in the cafe car are basically at Amtrak standard. Being Italy, however, your cappuccino is made fresh for you on the spot!
Circumvesuviana
If you have visited Pompeii, there is a good chance you have ridden the Circumvesuviana (“around Vesuvius”). This is the local, narrow-gauge train that runs along the Bay of Naples, connecting that city to the Pompeii excavation site, Sorrento, and towns in between. Riding the Circumvesuviana is a striking contrast to riding the Frecciarossa. It is a slow, jerky ride, with lots of local stops. And it is always standing-room-only crowded. The older trains are not air conditioned. With few seats and packed with straphangers, the ride reminds me of taking the Green Line to Fenway Park on game day in Boston! In fairness, the Campania regional government, which is responsible for this train, is doing what it can to improve service by buying new trainsets (story here) and eliminating redundant stops. But no amount of improvement on the service side can overcome the fact that large segments of the line are single-track, including a long single-track tunnel on the south end of the corridor. Solving that one is going to be difficult!
Ferries
Who doesn’t love a ferry ride? The Bay of Naples has an extensive ferry network. I rode only one – Sorrento to Capri and back – in off-season, so I can’t judge how crowded these boats are in summer. It was a good ride, and not even crowded – a rarity for Italy. What I found a bit confusing is that there are several ferries on this route, operated by different companies, and each with its own timetable and its own ticket office selling paper tickets. Definitely room for some operational improvements on the land side!
Capri funicular
Funiculars are great in the right application. The town of Capri is about 500 feet up from the island’s ferry landing, and the funicular is perfect for the location. It was pretty crowded in the “shoulder” season, so I’m sure it was a sweaty squeeze in August. Would not be easy to air-condition the ride!
Capri open-air taxis
It’s another 500 feet up from the main town of Capri to the smaller town of Anacapri, but the topography doesn’t lend itself to a funicular. The Italian solution? Open-air taxis. There is a bus, but the taxis are a lot faster and more fun (although pricier). The views are spectacular although the drive – like many Italian mountain roads – is pretty scary for the uninitiated.
City buses
I had not intended to ride a city bus in Italy, but found myself in Florence, with a full load of luggage and a wife with her arm in a cast, and unable to find a taxi. So we crammed on (Italian buses are always full) to a bus and jolted our way down narrow cobblestone streets to the train station. The buses are clean and modern – many of them electric – but it was not my mode of choice at the time. My only quibble with the service was that the bus stop nearest to the train station (Santa Maria Novella) was not conveniently located and required a bit of an (undesired) hike.
City streets
How do you squeeze legions of cars, buses, motorcycles, scooters, bicycles, and mobs of pedestrians (locals and tourists) down narrow cobblestone streets lined with shops, restaurants, and houses? With great difficulty! Italian cities deploy all the right techniques, including pedestrianization and restricted traffic zones, but most streets are still free-for-alls with pedestrians sometimes creating their own pedestrian-first zones through the tactical urbanism of sheer numbers! It’s a wonder that more people don’t get hurt through collisions or falls, although certainly some do (my wife came home with a broken elbow to prove the point).
Takeaways
I’m not sure there is much I can offer for U.S. policymakers, except maybe the obvious fact that if you create really convenient public transportation, people will use it. And car culture shouldn’t be a barrier: does the name “Ferrari” ring a bell?















